The Stava catastrophic failure of July 19, 1985 (Italy): technical-scientific data and socioeconomic aspects
Abstract
On July 19, 1985 at Stava near Tesero (Trento Region, northern Italy), two impoundments collapsed, causing the death of 268 people and the destruction
of many buildings. The two adjacent basins were constructed for the decantation and storage of fine-grained waste material (tailings), which was pumped
from a nearby fluorite mine. The consequences of the failure was a vast mudflow that found its way downstream along the Stava valley. The failure
occurred as a result of the collapse of the upper basin, which overwhelmed the lower basin. The mudflow continued down the valley destroying many
houses in the village of Stava, eventually reaching Tesero, where more property was destroyed or severely damaged. The disaster in the Stava valley was
one of the most tragic of its kind. With its high toll of lives lost and over 133 million euros in damage, it was one of the worst industrial catastrophes
anywhere in the world. This paper examines the technical errors, shortcomings, responsibilities and consequences of this disaster.
Read the full text
DOWNLOAD PDFReferences
Alexander, David E. 1986. “Northern Italian dam failure and mudflow, July 1985”. In: Disasters, Vol. 10, no. 1, The International
Journal of Disaster Studies and Practice, Foxcombe Publications, London: 3-7.
Carrera, Alessandro, Coop, Matthew R., and Lancellotta, Renato. 2011. “Influence of Grading on the Mechanical Behaviour of
Stava Tailings”. Géotechnique 61(11): 935-946.
Chandler, Richard J., and Tosatti, Giovanni. 1995. “The Stava tailings dams failure, Italy, July 1985”. Proc. Instn Civ. Engrs “Geotechnical
Engineering”, 113: 67-79.
Colombo, Pietro, Colleselli, Francesco, et Alii. 1986. “Risposta ai quesiti del Procuratore della Repubblica”. Technical Reports of
the Team of Experts of the Trento Courts, 12 reports, unpublished.
Colombo, Pietro, and Colleselli, Francesco. 2003. The collapse of the Stava tailings basins. Analysis of the event and observations.
In: G. Tosatti (ed.) “A review of scientific contributions on the Stava Valley disaster (Eastern Italian Alps), 19th July 1985”, Pitagora,
Bologna: 335-358.
De Battaglia, Franco. 2002. Prefazione. In: G. Lucchi (ed.) “Stava Perché”, 2nd Edition, Curcu & Genovese, Trento: 19.
Doglioni, Carlo. 1987. “Tectonics of the Dolomites (Southern Alps, Northern Italy)”. Journal of Structural Geology, 9: 181-193.
Genevois, Rinaldo, and Tecca, Pia R. 1993. “The tailings dams of Stava (northern Italy): an analysis of the disaster”. Proc. Int.
Conf. Environmental Management, Geo-Water and Engineering Aspects, Wollongong, Australia: 23-36.
Gens, Antonio, and Alonso, Eduardo E. 2006. “Aznalcóllar dam failure. Part 2: Stability conditions and failure mechanics”. Géotechnique,
(3): 185-201.
Gibson, Robert E. 1958. “The progress of consolidation in a clay layer increasing in thickness with time”. Géotechnique, 8: 171-182.
Giordani, Italo, Lucchi, Graziano, Salghetti Drioli, Giuseppe, and Tosatti, Giovanni. 2003. “Stava 1985. Una Documentazione”.
Curcu & Genovese, Trento, 96 p.
Govi, Mario, and Luino, Fabio. 2003. La colata di fango di Stava (Trentino) del 19 luglio 1985. In: G. Tosatti (ed.) “A review of scientific
contributions on the Stava Valley disaster (Eastern Italian Alps), 19th July 1985”, Pitagora, Bologna: 359-397.
ISMES 1986. “Indagini geotecniche di laboratorio su materiali provenienti dai bacini Prestavèl in località Stava-Tesero”. Technical
Report for the Team of Expert of the Trento Court, 5 Vols, unpublished.
Jamiolkowsky, Michele. 2014. “Soil mechanics and the observational method: challenges at the Żelazny Most copper tailings
disposal facility”. Géotechnique, 64(8): 590-618.
Lucchi, Graziano (ed.). 2005. Stava Perché. 3rd Edition, Curcu & Genovese, Trento, 254 p.
Lucchi, Graziano. 2011. “L’attività mineraria in Val di Stava”. In: Various Authors, Stava-Tesero. La ricostruzione e la memoria,
Fondazione Stava 1985, Comune di Tesero, Provincia Autonoma di Trento: 23-49.
Luino, Fabio, Tosatti, Giovanni, and Bonaria, Vittorio. 2014. “Dam Failures in the 20th Century: nearly 1,000 Avoidable Victims in
Italy Alone”. Journal of Environmental Science and Engineering, Vol. 3(1): 19-31.
Morgenstern, Norbert R., Vick, Steven G., and Van Zyl, Dirk. 2015. “Report on Mount Polley Tailings Storage Facility Breach,
January 30, 2015”. Independent Expert Engineering Investigation and Review Panel.
Morra, Angelo, and Vighi, Luciano. 1964. “Miniera di Prestavèl”. In: G. Perna (ed.) L’industria mineraria nel Trentino Alto Adige,
Trento.
Ricceri, Giuseppe. 2001. “Il crollo dei bacini di Stava”. In: Crolli e affidabilità delle strutture civili, 6-7 dicembre 2001, IUAV,
Venezia.
Rossi, Giovanni. 1973. “I bacini di decantazione degli impianti dei rifiuti di trattamento dei minerali. Aspetti ecologici e tecnoeconomici
del problema”. In: Industria Mineraria, 10-11, Serie II: 465-480 and 525-545, Roma.
Simeoni, Lucia and Tosatti, Giovanni. 2010. “Education in Mine Waste Engineering: the experience of SIGEO Master”. Proc. of the IV International Geomechanics Conference: Theory and Practice of Geomechanics for the effectiveness of mining production and
construction, Varna (Bulgaria), 3-6 June 2010: 691-698.
Takahashi, Tamotsu. 1991. “The big mud flow in the Stava River, Italy”. In: T. Takahashi (ed.), “Debris flow”, IAHR, Balkema, Rotterdam:
-99.
Tosatti, Giovanni. 2007. “La catastrofe della Val di Stava: cause e responsabilità”. Geoitalia, 20: 1-5.
Vick, Steven G. 1983. Planning, Design and Analysis of Tailings Dams. Wiley, New York.
Various Authors. 1989. Stava tre anni dopo. Edited by Associazione Sinistrati Val di Stava and Parish of Tesero, Cassa Rurale di
Tesero e Panchià, 79 p.
Various Authors. 2017. Foglio n. 44 “Predazzo” della Carta Geologica d’Italia alla scala 1:50.000. ISPRA, Servizio Geologico d’Italia,
Roma, in press.
Viola, Marco. 2011. “La ricostruzione”. In: Various Authors, Stava-Tesero. La ricostruzione e la memoria, Fondazione Stava 1985,
Comune di Tesero, Provincia Autonoma di Trento: 51-123.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12896/cse201700100111
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.
CSE Journal - City Safety Energy is a semiannual journal (Two ISSUES per Year) published by Le Penseur in Brienza (PZ) - Italy | ISSN print edition 2283-8767 | ISSN online edition 2284-3418 - Journal registerd at the Court of Potenza (Italy) n. 219/2014